Energy subscription via shared generation in the sights of the TCU

Body authorizes opening of representation to investigate possible energy sales practices in rental models
Sale of energy via shared generation is in the TCU’s sights
TCU accepted representation from AudElétrica regarding possible irregularities. Photo: Senado Agency/Reproduction

O TCU (Federal Audit Court) determined the opening an investigation before alleged signs of illegal commercialization of energy credits electricity within the scope of segment of distributed micro and minigeneration.

A decision was taken after AudElétrica (Specialized Audit Unit for Electrical and Nuclear Energy), file a representation against the ANEEL (National Electric Energy Agency), aiming to implement supervisory actions and improve regulation on energy subscriptions.

According to AudElétrica's preliminary understanding, the current “subscription” models, in which the generating plant is leased, present “a characteristic analogous to commercialization within the captive market”.

“This is not a simple representation. O AudElétrica document contains 35 pages, is very well-founded and includes an examination of specific cases of companies that operate in this market, offering discounts on energy bills”, highlights Thiago Bao Ribeiro, lawyer specializing in GD (distributed generation) and CEO of the firm Bao Ribeiro Advogados.

According to a the representation of AudElectricaThe analyzed companies offer “energy signature”, whose business models point to a irregular sale of electricity in the CESG (Electrical Energy Compensation System).

“The arguments presented for attracting customers suggest a covert sale of energy/energy credits/surplus energy”, highlights the representation.

O document also did not spare distributors that operate in this segment. Advertising and contracts with consumers from the main energy distributors that operate in distributed micro and minigeneration were analyzed.

According to the TCU, the role of distributors in this market has potential conflict of interest.

“Add to this a systematic interpretation and the topographic structure of Law 14.300/2022, which invariably place concessionaires and SCEE participants on opposite sides.”

As possible causes of this situation, the TCU listed failures in the inspection of ANEEL, regulatory failures, high tariffs, ease of creating and changing associations and cooperatives, with characteristics of illegality in the arrangements created, ease of changing the ownership of consumer units to use the remote self-consumption or distributed generation modality, among others.

O TCU minister, Antonio Anastasia, welcomed the representation, determining (in short) that ANEEL:

● Be heard within 15 days regarding signs of irregularity;
● Develop, within 60 days, an inspection plan to identify and eventually sanction cases of commercialization, even if indirectly, of energy, credits or surplus electricity from MMGD;
● Prepare, within 80 days, an action plan to regulate the matter;
● Include in the aforementioned action plan actions regarding the situation of projects already classified as micro and mini distributed generation.

According to Bao Ribeiro, the TCU’s decision introduces a “unnecessary legal uncertainty, calling into question arrangements already established and recognized by the Regulatory Agency, which are also ed by federal legislation (Law 14.300/2022), responsible for establishing the legal framework for distributed generation in the country,” he said.

Due to this representation, the lawyer highlights that more than ever it is “urgent” that DG entrepreneurs review their contracts so as not to be excluded from the GD. “It is possible that the contracts are within the four lines of current regulations”, he highlighted.


all the content of Canal Solar is protected by copyright law, and partial or total reproduction of this site in any medium is expressly prohibited. If you are interested in collaborating or reusing part of our material, please us by email: [email protected].

Photo by Henrique Hein
Henrique Hein
He worked at Correio Popular and Rádio Trianon. He has experience in podcast production, radio programs, interviews and reporting. Has been following the solar sector since 2020.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Comments should be respectful and contribute to a healthy debate. Offensive comments may be removed. The opinions expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the author. Canal Solar.

News from Canal Solar in your Email

Posts

Receive the latest news

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

<
<
Canal Solar
Privacy

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.